Although some believed him to be a rightwing fanatic, rehnquist was easily confirmed by the senate. During confirmation hearings, rehnquist was grilled about the memo to which he responded that the memo accurately reflected justice jacksons views at the time it was written and was not pensive of his own views. Testifying with the precision and authority of a veteran trial attorney, brosnahan noted that rehnquist, at his 1971 confirmation hearings as an associate justice, told the senate panel that he had tried to arbitrate disputes at phoenix polling places and had not personally engaged in challenging the qualifications of any voters. This is a pdf of a folder from our textual collections. Comparison with rehnquist hearings author and former nixon white house counsel john dean will write, it was clear that thomas was going the route that supreme court justice william rehnquist had traveled see september 26, 1986. Senate calendar latest issue executive calendar latest issue, pdf previous meeting tuesday, may 05, 2020 the senate convened at 11. Bush announced that he would nominate judge john roberts as the supreme courts, 17th chief justice on september 5, 2005, two days after the death of chief justice william rehnquist, and five weeks after selecting him as an associate justice to succeed retiring justice sandra day oconnor.
An empirical analysis of the confirmation hearings of the. For example, at justice rehnquists confirmation hearings, senator ken. Senate judiciary committee begins confirmation hearings of. Daily digest latest issue congressional record latest issue, pdf tentative floor schedule. An empirical analysis of the confirmation hearings of the justices of. When available, links to full hearing transcripts are provided. Proffitt n january 1983, justice rehnquist completed his eleventh year as an associate justice of the united states supreme court. Czarnezki marquette university school of law william k. Prior to confirmation hearings for judge john roberts, a compilation of the senate judiciary committee hearings for justice william rehnquists nomination as chief justice was shown.
The memo was titled a random thought on the segregation cases, one of which was brown v. Nomination hearings for supreme court justices listed below are the dates of selected supreme court nominees hearings before the senate judiciary committee since 1971. In confirmation hearings, roberts says he will promote unanimity stare decisis says a justices job is like an umpire in baseball who just calls balls and strikes the last two terms, the court has had the largest percentage of 54 or 63 decisions in. Number of days from nomination to first committee hearing. During the hearings, witnesses, both supporting and opposing the nomination, present their views. Did william rehnquist lie to become a justice, and then chief. Index to unreleased justice deprtmertt documents in rehnquist hearing. Senate judiciary committee begins confirmation hearings of supreme court nominee antonin scalia bob jamieson, anchor. October 1, 1924 september 3, 2005 was an american jurist and lawyer who served on the supreme court of the united states for 33 years, first as an associate justice from 1972 to 1986 and then as the chief justice from 1986 until his death in 2005.
Telling the story of justice rehnquists nomination findlaw. The senate judiciary committee holds a hearing on the nominee. October 1, 1924 september 3, 2005 was an american jurist and lawyer who served on the supreme court of the. In contrast, nixons october 1971 appointment of lewis f. Judge antonin scalia, chosen to replace rehnquist on the supreme court, is facing an easier time in his confirmation hearings. Roberts nominee to replace chief justice williams h. And there is every indication to expect that the alito hearings will be conducted with the same kind of respect that the ginsburg, breyer, and roberts confirmation hearings.
Court of the united states has been asked by the senate judiciary committee at his confirmation hearings whether he believed in a living constitution. This essay argues that rehnquists 1955 letter represents his disappointment with brown and the beginning of his outspoken criticism of the warren court. Mackenzie, controversy deepens over rehnquist memo, wash. The record of more than a decade is extensive enough to permit serious appraisal of his work, and. Weighing the evidence carefully, dean draws the unequivocal conclusion that rehnquist, like the man who appointed him, lied repeatedly perhaps, in. Senate confirmation hearings for supreme court nominees have in recent years grown increasingly contentious. Throughout his tenure, justice rehnquist was conventionally perceived as a conservative, partly for the anticivil rights memos he had written earlier in his career. A short history of rightwing lies in supreme court confirmation hearings neil gorsuchs bland denials belong to a tradition of conservative dishonesty that. Hearing before the committee on the judiciary, united states senate, january 29, 2003 and hearings before the committee on the judiciary, united states senate, april 20, may 7, may 22, june 25, and july 9, 2003 in which judge robertss january 29, 2003 appearance and his april 30, 2003 appearance for his federal court confirmation hearings. Nomination hearings associate justice rehnquist library of.
The 1955 letter was not known during rehnquists 1971 or 1986 confirmation hearings. If the hearings reveal substantively valuable information about nominees\u27. Rehnquist took his seat on the court in january 1972. For example, at justice rehnquist s confirmation hearings, senator kennedy termed him an extremist. Senate judiciary committee hearings for supreme court.
Senate confirmed roberts as 17th chief justice september 29. As the hearings on solicitor general kagans nomination wind down, my sense is that, while we can say that they were an improvement over the alito hearings in that democratic senators did not so insult the nominee as to cause her loved ones in the hearing room to cry, and also that at least some of the questions and answers. Hearings for supreme court nominations since 1949 supreme court nominations from 1949 to 2016 routinely received public confirmation hearings before either the senate judiciary committee or a judiciary subcommittee for a discussion of the nature of such hearings prior to 1949, see crs report r44236. An empirical analysis of the confirmation hearings of the justices of the rehnquist natural court constitutional commentary, vol. Given the focus of this symposiumempirical and mathematical inquiries of the rehnquist courtwe focus on the rehnquist natural court the period from 1994 to 2005 when the same nine justices served together. Nomination of william rehnquist as supreme court chief. Law and politics in judicial confirmation hearings introduction senate confirmation hearings for supreme court nominees have in recent years grown increasingly contentious.
The following day, bush officially nominated roberts to. University of minnesota law school, 2007 view download file. During his clerkship, which began in 1952, rehnquist wrote two highly controversial memos to jackson that would provoke firestorms during his own confirmation hearings, in 1971 and 1986. Hearings and reports on successful and unsuccessful nominations of supreme court justices by the senate judiciary committee, 1916197519161994 compiled by roy m. The committee usually takes a month to collect and receive all necessary records, from the fbi and other sources, about the nominee and for the nominee to be prepared for the hearings. Ringhand introduction the interpretive or judicial philosophies of supreme court justices can be thought of as packages of beliefs about how to. Committee hearings for justice william rehnquists nomination. The judicial philosophy of justice rehnquist by robert e. It is also currently missing and may have been stolen from frankfurters papers at the library of congress. Nomination of william rehnquist as supreme court chief justice brings controversy bob jamieson, anchor. Excerpts from the chief justice confirmation hearing of supreme court judge william rehnquist featured questioning of judge rehnquist by senate judiciary committee members strom thurmond and joseph. After extended and often heated senate committee hearings, rehnquist was finally confirmed by the senate by a vote of 6826 in december 1971.
Say anything that was necessary to win confirmation, regardless of the conspicuousness of the lie. Prior to confirmation hearings for judge john roberts, a compilation of the. Judicial philosophy of justice rehnquist, the the university of akron. Since we know of no other study that attempts to measure confirmation hearing statements, we hope this symposium piece facilitates further discussion on how one might best evaluate confirmation hearing statements, and, thus, how we might. As a member of the supreme court, justice rehnquist has been quick to seize. Despite the importance of this question, surprisingly little work has been done comparing the statements made by nominees at their confirmation hearings with their subsequent behavior on the supreme court. But dean does address at length another issue of considerable importance, namely, rehnquists character and, specifically, the question of whether rehnquist lied in his confirmation hearings. In remembering rehnquists legacy on the court, and with an eye towards john roberts confirmation hearings next week, liberals should join conservatives in seeking to protect and extend this. Supreme courtrehnquistscalia press clippings ronald reagan. Illustrative of its specific work is the monumental criminal defense manual.
1531 781 698 332 478 1453 586 290 1294 1064 896 792 1155 713 931 1072 297 461 21 598 785 1180 1139 851 1193 830 567 568 1362 498 384 818